Giving damaged cards a second chance.
Connect with me in person to hand off your card for restoration.
Updates from the bench.
At Restored Rarity, restoration goes far beyond surface cleaning. It is a careful, detail-driven process designed to bring each card as close as possible to its original appearance while preserving the character and history that make it unique.
From deep creases, dents, and pressure marks to edge damage, surface imperfections, warping, delamination, and years of accumulated wear, every card presents a different challenge. That's why there is no one-size-fits-all approach. Each card is individually evaluated, and the restoration process is tailored to its specific condition, construction, and damage.
Some cards respond beautifully in a single session. Others require multiple rounds, specialized techniques, and patience to address years of wear or the card's natural tendency to retain a “memory” of previous damage. Every step is approached carefully and deliberately, with the goal of achieving the best result the card can realistically provide.
Restoration is as much about judgment and patience as it is technique. Knowing how a card responds, when to continue, when to adjust the approach, and when the best possible result has been achieved is an important part of the process.
Whether you're looking to revive a childhood favorite, improve the presentation of a centerpiece in your collection, prepare a card for grading evaluation, or give new life to a card you thought was beyond saving, Restored Rarity is dedicated to the cards worth preserving.
Your collection has a history. Let us preserve it.
A few cards that came through the shop recently.
Every tier below builds on services offered from the previous. Pick the one that matches how far your card needs to go.
A meticulous cleaning performed under magnification to safely lift dirt, grime, fingerprints, and surface buildup while restoring the card's natural presentation and holo brilliance. Does not include scratch repair or buffing.Bulk pricing: $8/card for 21–40 cards, $6/card for 41+ cards.
Everything included in our Card Cleaning service, with additional surface refinement and precision buffing to reduce visible scratches, scuffs, and holo wear while preserving the card's original finish.
Our most comprehensive grading-prep service. Includes a detailed evaluation under magnification, deep cleaning, scratch and surface refinement, identification and correction of addressable surface defects, and minor corner or edge flattening where appropriate. Your card is cleaned, evaluated, refined, and ready to submit.
Targeted restoration for localized damage, including minor corner or edge lifting, dents or gouges under ¼ inch, and creases under ½ inch. Each repair is carefully addressed to stabilize the affected area and restore the card as close as possible to its original appearance.
Advanced restoration for significant damage, including major corner or edge lifting, delamination or layer separation, dents or gouges over ¼ inch, and creases over ½ inch. Designed for cards requiring more extensive techniques, additional working time, or multiple rounds of restoration to achieve the best result possible.
Careful removal of your card from a graded slab so it can be cleaned, restored, or resubmitted. The slab is opened with care to protect the card's surface, edges, and corners.Only $10 when combined with another service.
My grading submission fee ($15 for the first card and for each one after on its own, or $5 per card added to another service) covers evaluating, packaging and sending your card to the grading company you choose: PSA, CGC, BGS or TAG.
The grading company’s own fees are paid in stages, based on the base fee for the service level you picked:
For cards with a card value of $250 or less, no value surcharge applies.
For repair services, a surcharge is added to the selected service price based on the card's estimated value (based on natural wear, excluding any damage; see below): 10% for cards between $251 and $1,500, and 12% for cards between $1,501 and $3,000, rounded up to the nearest dollar. Cards valued above $3,000 require a custom quote. Cleaning and evaluation services are never subject to a value surcharge.
Your card’s estimated value is based on its natural wear, excluding any damage. We use current market sales (comps) for that condition, so normal wear like whitening, edge wear or scratches outside the holo area counts toward the value, while damage such as creases, dents, bends, tears or holo scratches is left out.
Example: a creased card that otherwise shows light edge wear is valued using sales of the same card with that light wear and no crease, not top-condition prices. You only pay a surcharge on what your card is realistically worth.
Measure each border, front and back, to see your exact centering percentages and which grades your card qualifies for.
Tell me about your card(s) and what they need. Photos appreciated — front and back: Submitting more than one card? Add as many as you need below.
Enter the reference number from your confirmation email and the email you submitted with to see where your cards are.
What collectors have said about their restorations.
Before-and-afters, works in progress and show updates.
Read through before submitting or shipping your cards.
Start by completing the Restored Rarity Submission Form above. You'll provide your contact information, details about each card, its estimated card value, and the cleaning or restoration service you're interested in.
Submitting the form begins the process, but it does not mean you should ship your cards yet.
Once your form has been submitted, you'll receive an automatic confirmation email letting you know your request was successfully received.
From there, I'll personally review your submission and follow up by email. We'll confirm your requested services, discuss any questions about the cards or damage, review shipping details and costs, and provide an estimated restoration timeline.
Shipping costs are passed through to the customer and are separate from the cost of your selected services.
During our initial communication, I'll confirm the shipping method, cost, insurance/value information, and other necessary details with you. Once everything is confirmed and I'm ready to receive your submission, I'll provide your shipping label and shipping instructions by email.
Return shipping will also be coordinated with you, with appropriate shipping and insurance based on the value of the cards being returned.
Cards should be packaged carefully to protect against movement, bending, moisture, and impact during transit.
I recommend following the general card-shipping practices outlined by PSA: cards should be individually protected with a penny sleeve and semi-rigid holder such as a Card Saver, kept in the same order as your submission when possible, and secured with appropriate rigid support and cushioning inside a sturdy shipping box.
Avoid packaging that places unnecessary pressure directly on the cards or allows them to move freely inside the package.
Specific packaging and shipping instructions will also be provided before you send your submission.
Once received, your cards will be documented and physically inspected. I'll compare their condition with the information provided on your submission and confirm that the requested services are appropriate for the damage present.
Photos don't always tell the entire story. If the physical inspection reveals additional damage, a different repair level, or something that changes the scope or cost of the restoration, I'll contact you before proceeding.
There are no surprise upgrades or additional repairs performed without communication when they would change what we originally discussed.
Turnaround time varies with every submission and will be discussed with you during our initial emails before you ship your cards.
Card restoration isn't a one-size-fits-all process. A cleaning or minor repair may be relatively straightforward, while significant creases, dents, lifting, edge damage, or delamination can require multiple rounds of treatment, different techniques, and appropriate drying or stabilization time.
Some damage can also have a natural tendency to retain “memory,” making patience and additional rounds necessary to achieve a more stable result.
The priority is always achieving the best and most stable result the card will realistically allow—not rushing a restoration to meet an arbitrary turnaround time.
If circumstances significantly change the expected timeline while your cards are with me, I'll communicate that with you.
No. If I discover damage that falls outside the service or repair level we originally discussed, I'll contact you first.
I'll explain what I found, what I recommend, and any difference in price before performing additional work that would change your approved service.
Value surcharges apply to repair services only — cleaning and evaluation services are never subject to a surcharge, no matter the card's value.
For repairs, cards with a card value of $250 or less do not have a card-value surcharge.
For repairs on cards valued between $251 and $1,500, a surcharge of 10% of the card's value is added to the selected service price. For cards valued between $1,501 and $3,000, the surcharge rate is 12%. All surcharges are rounded up to the nearest dollar.
Cards valued above $3,000 are individually reviewed and require a custom quote.
No two damaged cards respond exactly the same way, so a specific cosmetic result cannot be guaranteed.
Restoration can significantly improve defects, but evidence of the original damage may sometimes remain. For example, a repaired crease may leave surface scarring, rubs, or changes to the foil appearance even though the crease itself has been corrected.
Damage memory can also occasionally cause a faint indication of previous damage to reappear after a restoration.
This is restoration, not alteration. The goal is to carefully correct what can be corrected while preserving the card and achieving the best result it will realistically allow.
No. Grade-Ready Evaluations are evaluations—not grading guarantees.
I can identify defects, address eligible issues, clean and prepare the card, and provide my assessment of its grading potential. However, PSA, TAG, CGC, BGS, or any other third-party grading company independently determines the final grade.
Communication is a major part of the Restored Rarity process. The email address provided on your submission form will be the primary method of communication for:
Submission confirmation and initial review, estimated turnaround, shipping labels and instructions, service or repair recommendations, pricing changes requiring approval, restoration updates when necessary, and completion, payment, and return shipping.
Please use an email address you regularly check and keep an eye on your inbox after submitting.
Once your restoration is complete, I'll contact you with the final details and coordinate getting your cards safely back to you.
Your cards will be securely packaged for their return trip, and return shipping and applicable insurance costs will be passed through to you and confirmed before shipment.
From the moment you submit your request until your cards make their way home, the goal is simple: clear communication, careful handling, and no surprises.
Restorations, before/afters, and drop-in availability at shows.